Alright, alright, sorry for the corny post title.
I just found out yesterday that MLB is planning to incorporate the ABS (Automated Ball Strike challenge system) full-time in 2026.
For anybody who isn't exactly sure what this system means, it allows a batter, pitcher, or catcher to challenge a ball or strike call, and then using certain technology, the pitch will be determined either ball or strike, and the call changed if a changed is deemed necessary (this might have come in handy when I played rec ball).
Some think that this is a bad innovation, claiming that MLB needs less change to the rules, and doesn't need robots making calls for umpires. I've seen comments saying that human error is a part of the game and should not be changed.
Others argue that this makes the game more accurate and fair for every team. They have gone on to say that human error should not be a part of the game since there is a very set strike zone. I have seen a number of comments suggesting that MLB should go with fully automated strike zones and take out the home plate umpire altogether.
Yankees manager Aaron Boone does not like the new system, claiming that Yankee backstops are the best at framing in the game. While this is certainly a bold statement, he does seem to have a point that this system will render the ever-delicate art of framing useless.
From the same article cited above, the Orioles call this installment a 'happy marriage between tradition and modern times.' Although I am unsure where the tradition comes into play.
Phillies manager Rob Thompson also likes the ABS system, and believes that most (though not all) of the players will also enjoy it.
There are some mixed opinions on the system, but it seems that the major league consensus is in favor of the new rule's implementation. However, one can only wonder how many new rules will be added into the game and the tension such new rules will cause between the players and the owners.
What do y'all think about this rule? I'd love to hear what your opinions on this subject are, and if they are as mixed as those of the major leaguers.
Based on the general enjoyment of the ABS system being incorporated into the game, there shouldn't be a lockout over this particular rule. However, I have heard that tensions are already building due to talks of salary caps. Let's just not see any more fighting gentleman, please.
I'm OK with the rule in it's currently limited state. I like the fact that the challenge is strictly reserved to the pitcher, catcher, and batter. It'll add a level of strategy. Does a hitter potentially burn a challenge in the 1st inning, giving his team less opportunity when it might matter more? Will a pitcher challenge a strikeout pitch when a double-play would get him out of a troublesome inning? It'll be interesting to see whose ego gets the best of them and which players truly have an eye for the strike zone...
ReplyDelete